If you own a pool in Savannah, the pool heater vs heat pump question usually comes up right after the first cool weekend of fall. There is no single right answer, but there is a clear way to decide: look at what an hour of heat costs with each fuel, then match that to how your household actually swims.
The short answer
- A heat pump costs the least to run and is the better fit for keeping a pool warm for weeks at a time.
- A full-size gas heater heats nearly three times faster than a typical heat pump and is the better fit for spas and last-minute weekends.
- If your gas comes from a propane tank, the running-cost gap gets very wide.
What an hour of heat costs in Savannah right now
We priced these in early October 2026 using Georgia Power’s posted residential rate, the Georgia Public Service Commission’s natural gas price chart and the federal Energy Information Administration’s Georgia propane survey. All figures are approximate and your bill will differ.
Heat pump. Georgia Power’s residential energy charge from October through May is about 8.2 cents per kWh. With the fuel charge, riders and fees it lands near 13.5 to 15 cents. A heat pump putting out 120,000 BTU an hour at an efficiency (COP) of 5 uses about 7 kWh, so it costs roughly $0.95 to $1.05 an hour.
Natural gas heater. A 400,000 BTU heater burns 4 therms an hour. At $0.70 to $1.80 per therm, that is roughly $2.80 to $7.20 an hour. The low end reflects fixed-rate plans; the high end reflects last winter’s average delivered price for Georgia homes with all charges included.
Propane heater. The same heater burns about 4.4 gallons an hour. At $2.95 to $3.20 per gallon, that is roughly $12.90 to $14.00 an hour.
An hour is not the same amount of heat, though. At the federal minimum efficiency of 82 percent, the gas heater puts about 328,000 BTU into the water in that hour, against 120,000 for the heat pump. Evened out to the same heat delivered:
- Heat pump: about $0.65 to $1.10 per 100,000 BTU
- Natural gas: about $0.85 to $2.20
- Propane: about $3.90 to $4.30
In South Carolina, or on an electric co-op, plug in the rates from your own bill.
Pool heater vs heat pump for three kinds of Savannah owners
You want to swim from March into November
This is heat pump territory. You are asking the heater to hold a temperature day after day while the air is mild, which is exactly what a heat pump does cheaply. Pair it with a cover. The U.S. Department of Energy says a cover can cut pool heating costs by 50 to 70 percent.
You heat the spa, or the pool a few weekends a year
Gas makes more sense. Warming a 20,000-gallon pool by 8 degrees for a Saturday takes about 1.33 million BTU. A 400,000 BTU gas heater does that in about four hours for roughly $11 to $29 on natural gas. A heat pump would need about eleven hours, more on a cool day, for roughly $9 to $15. You save a little money and lose most of a day. For a spa you want hot in 30 minutes, gas is the only practical choice.
Your gas is propane
That same weekend warm-up runs roughly $52 to $57 on propane. Do it a dozen times a season and the fuel alone is real money. One common setup is to keep the gas heater for the spa and add a heat pump for the pool.
How Savannah weather affects a heat pump
A heat pump pulls its heat from outdoor air, and the Department of Energy says it works efficiently while that air stays above roughly 45 to 50°F. NOAA’s 30-year normals for Savannah show:
- April, May and October: average highs of 78 to 85°F and lows of 55 to 63°F. Ideal heat pump weather.
- March and November: highs around 70°F, lows in the upper 40s. Still workable, slower in the morning.
- December through February: highs in the low to mid 60s and average lows of 40 to 43°F. A heat pump struggles on those nights.
If you want a warm pool at Christmas, plan on gas.
What about the cost to install?
It depends on the equipment and the site, so we quote each job instead of posting a number. The things that move the price:
- Heater size and model
- For gas: the distance to the meter or tank, line size and venting
- For a heat pump: whether your breaker panel has room for a new dedicated circuit, and clear space around the unit for airflow
- Any replumbing at the equipment pad
The Department of Energy notes that heat pumps generally cost more to buy than gas heaters and less to operate.
Talk to Perfect Pools about a heater upgrade
Perfect Pools installs and repairs gas heaters and heat pumps in Savannah, Pooler, Garden City, Wilmington Island, Skidaway Island, Tybee Island, Richmond Hill, Rincon and Bluffton. We will look at your pool, your fuel and your electrical service and give you a straight recommendation.
- Richmond Hill: (912) 459-0160
- Savannah / Garden City: (912) 303-7372
- Email: info@perfectpoolscleaning.com
Having trouble with the heater you already own? Start with our guide to a pool heater that won’t start, or browse the blog.
Common questions
Is a heat pump or a gas heater cheaper to run in Savannah?
The heat pump, for the same amount of heat. Natural gas on a low fixed rate comes close. Propane costs several times more.
What does a heat pump pool heater cost to run per hour?
About a dollar an hour for a 120,000 BTU unit at Georgia Power’s October through May rates. How many hours it runs depends on your pool, the weather and whether you cover it.
Can a heat pump heat my spa?
Yes, but slowly. Expect an hour or more where a gas heater takes about 30 minutes.
Do heat pumps work in winter here?
On mild days, yes. On nights in the low 40s their output drops, and they may not keep up.